ny Date: 02-16-2026

List 12 Restaurants Near You Open Sunday in Herkimer, NY

Find the top 12 budget-friendly restaurants near you in Herkimer, NY, ideal for cheap, tasty, and satisfying meals.

RestaurantsAddressPrice_level
1The Meltdown701 Mohawk St, Herkimer, NY 13350Moderate
2Burger King115 W State St, Herkimer, NY 13350Inexpensive
3Arbys306 E State St, Herkimer, NY 13350Inexpensive
4Caffe’ Maya208 S Main St, Herkimer, NY 13350Undetermined
5Taco Bell / KFC200 S Caroline St, Herkimer, NY 13350Inexpensive
6Yettys Pizza109 Mohawk St, Herkimer, NY 13350Moderate
7Tonys Pizzeria435 Mohawk St, Herkimer, NY 13350Inexpensive
8P Ks Pub221 King St, Herkimer, NY 13350Moderate
9Asteroga Ale House122 W Albany St, Herkimer, NY 13350Inexpensive
10Tokyo Sushi100 N Caroline St, Herkimer, NY 13350Moderate
11KFC200 S Caroline St, Herkimer, NY 13350Inexpensive
12Crazy Ottos Empire Diner100 W Albany St, Herkimer, NY 13350Inexpensive

1.The Meltdown

Address: 701 Mohawk St, Herkimer, NY 13350

(9) user ratings total:

Don Peterson Excellent Quality !! Looking forward to a return visit
5 /5

2.Burger King

Address: 115 W State St, Herkimer, NY 13350

(868) user ratings total:

Paige Love how nicely they package the food most of the time, like they actually take their time. Food is always out in a timely manner. Never had any real issues here, other than the occasional tiny mistake. And Im absolutely obsessed with the Spicy Deluxe chicken Sandwich. Handbreaded, huge, and a flavor to die for. Better than any other places competing sandwich by far.
4 /5

3.Arbys

Address: 306 E State St, Herkimer, NY 13350

(746) user ratings total:

Donald Wisniewski Arbys is extremely underrated, and for fast food is extremely well made. If you are not going to a local restaurant, Arbys a great option. Plus the cheesesteak is superb.
5 /5

4.Caffe’ Maya

Address: 208 S Main St, Herkimer, NY 13350

(72) user ratings total:

Joe Rocco Excellent Italian food ! Had an antipasto and chicken parm….was outstanding! Staff and owner very nice people. Can bring your own wine. Will definitely be back.
5 /5

5.Taco Bell / KFC

Address: 200 S Caroline St, Herkimer, NY 13350

(692) user ratings total:

Kqthryn I am a very loyal customer to taco bell and kfc but i honestly wouldn’t really want to go to this location again. Last night they told me to pull around for my one item and I ended up waiting over 10 minutes, I pulled around the drive thru and sat there while people looked at me, someone finally came up and I politely said I was waiting on a burrito I paid for, and she grabbed it for me, the burrito was alright but then I told her I got a large baja blast with no ice that was completely flat, and asked if she could get me a new one. she proceeded to tell me that all the soda are flat right now and now i’m thinking in my head why would they serve me something that is flat knowingly? She told me she could get me a lemonade or fruit punch and I ended up getting a small lemonade with ice.
3 /5

6.Yettys Pizza

Address: 109 Mohawk St, Herkimer, NY 13350

(661) user ratings total:

Miguel-Angel Jimenez 2nd time coming here ...never had anything that tasted or even looked like turf. Dont understand the comparison. Wings are good, fried banana peppers were good and pizza was delicious. Would definitely recommend. They also have a homemade sangria thats really good... must try! ...place looks really cozy with plenty of seating. Dessert menu is extensive and seems to be all home made which is always a plus.
5 /5

7.Tonys Pizzeria

Address: 435 Mohawk St, Herkimer, NY 13350

(423) user ratings total:

Neil Kitty In the middle of a roadtrip we stopped off strictly because the reviews were awesome. Man, so glad we did!! I got the chicken cesar salad and the garlic pizza. These portions lasted me for like 3 days!! Service was so attentive and they are experts at what they do. It was clean for the most part, but right before closing so I figured no biggie. The bathroom was very decent. Prices are reasonable and youre supporting a small business so why not. Will visit again when in the area!
5 /5

8.P Ks Pub

Address: 221 King St, Herkimer, NY 13350

(376) user ratings total:

Jennifer Shadduck Love this place! Had a fantastic first experience and will definitely make PKs a regular stop for a few brewskies, a great meal, or both! We had a party of 5 and were seated right away. EVERYONE was super friendly and attentive to our needs. It was obvious the employees enjoyed their jobs, lots of smiles and great attitudes, made for a really enjoyable atmosphere. Our appetizers were brought out quickly and we were able to enjoy our drinks and munchies while our entrées were prepared. I wish I got more pics because everything looked awesome! All food was brought out hot and all together, just a few minutes after we finished our apps. Now let me just say, greens are an absolute favorite of mine, I order them everywhere, every chance I get. Hands down! PKs NAILS IT with their greens! Dare I say, theyre the best Ive had. Theres no way I cant order them every time I go in now. The food was on point, so delicious, and everyone was very satisfied. Prices are totally reasonable as well. So happy we decided to check PKs out!
5 /5

9.Asteroga Ale House

Address: 122 W Albany St, Herkimer, NY 13350

(363) user ratings total:

Misty Garafalo Maxine was our server, she was super from start to finish! We had several dishes from the Calamari to the Italian Burger to the Bacon Cheddar Burger, Roasted Red pepper Gouda bisque, Tuscan chicken panini, Buffalo Mac and Cheese,the Everything Wings were to die for BTW and the taco salad. The guys had some craft beers and the blackberry strawberry cider. Great atmosphere and place to stop while traveling through..... Service top notch, food even better!
5 /5

10.Tokyo Sushi

Address: 100 N Caroline St, Herkimer, NY 13350

(359) user ratings total:

Lisa Delicious sushi!!! Love seeing our friend: she works so hard.
4 /5

11.KFC

Address: 200 S Caroline St, Herkimer, NY 13350

(205) user ratings total:

Dayna Campbell I’ve ordered from KFC quite bit, maybe 1-2 a month for the past nearly 18 months. Each and every time I order there is an issue. Typically I order through the KFC app. 99% of the time, the chicken type distribution is wrong (e.g. I order “dark meat” but I get white meat) and I typically call to receive some correction. This time I’m appalled because the one time they got the chicken right, it comes soggy (skin separated in chunks in the wet bucket, lots of moisture trapped in the bag ) and without the four sauces I ordered that are listed on the digital receipt AND the one taped on the bag. KFC is the only place that I haven’t seen really optimize and update their to-go packaging. The plastic traps the heat and encourages everything to sweat. They could take a note from places like Rick’s Famous Burgers in Utica. Additionally, as someone who was a Door Dasher and is a consistent customer, it’s disappointing that they don’t check the food when packaging and giving to customers. I NEVER see the list checked off or the name of the team member who reviewed the food while packaging. My delivery driver wouldn’t have been able to check for the sauces anyway because of the safety packaging (which I do appreciate as someone who gets delivery). KFC in general has gone down in quality in general over the years and it’s things like this that are particularly disappointing. Spending $90 only to be disappointed because the condiments weren’t there is irritating. This could have been easily avoided with a simple check of the bag. Maybe if they did that, I would have gotten my full order without the random drink I DIDN’T order. On a positive note, I truly feel like the attitude and demeanor of the employees has improved over the last few months. I don’t go inside often but the newer people I wasn’t familiar with before have been very polite upon entry into the store.
2 /5

12.Crazy Ottos Empire Diner

Address: 100 W Albany St, Herkimer, NY 13350

images Crazy Ottos Empire Diner

(1840) user ratings total:

J.R. Ferrerio Good old 1950s stainless steel diner. One of the last 5 in operation in the USA! Good food, friendly people, and a very pleasant experience.
5 /5